The Subtle Knife

Author: Philip Pullman
Publisher: Random House Children's Books
Publication Date: 1997
Series: His Dark Materials; Book 2
Age Range: 10+
Short Plot Summary: The second volume of this trilogy finds Lyra in the new land of Cittagazze, a land where children wander the deserted towns unattended, and soul-stealing Specters lay lurking. Lyra soon makes an ally in 12 year-old Will Parry who has also stumbled into the new world. Will comes into possession of a beautiful unbelievably sharp knife which has the power to cut portals from one world into the next. Lyra and Will set off on a quest to discover the whereabouts of Will's missing father and Lyra tries to learn more about Dust. The children encounter many dangerous situations and intriguing characters including the scientist Mary Malone, Sir Charles and the return of Mrs. Coulter and Lee Scoresby. The story ends on a cliffhanger with the fate of the world, the war and young Lyra all up in the air.

Evaluative Comments: As I said with the first novel (The Golden Compass), I think that this book features advanced concepts and illusions which may be beyond the comprehension level of younger readers (9 and younger).
I thought Pullman was more heavy-handed in this book than the last in pushing his own anti- authoritarian views down the throat of the reader. It overshadowed all other aspects of the book, and I grew tired of it by the end.
This book featured a lot of violence, and therefore I might not recommend it to younger readers. I found the scene where Will and Lyra were being attacked by the Cittigazze town children to be particularly disturbing.
I think the fantasy world Pullman has created again is original and complex. The book is fast-paced and I found it hard to put down once I started reading. The last two chapters in particular are full of suspense. I enjoyed the introduction of the character Will and his role in the action. I think that Will might increase the book's appeal to a male audience.


Rating: 4/5

No comments: