Before You Were Big

Author: Jennifer Davis
Illustrator: Jennifer Cornell
Publisher: Workman Publishing
Publication Date: 2003
Award: N/A
Age Range: Baby-Preschool
Short Plot Summary: This books answers typical question young children might have about their first year life. Each two-page spread describes how a baby develops and changes month by month.
Evaluative Comments:
I see this book functioning best in preparing a young child for a new sibling that might be entering the family. I felt like the book was written more for adults than children, as the there was a lot of text to each page, and the content itself was heavy-handed and even came off as condescending at times. The rhyming verse felt labored at times and featured advanced vocabulary beyond the comprehension level of young readers.
I really liked the flap feature on each page, and think it would work best for children that were being read to do as it's an interactive feature which would keep children engaged with the story being read.
At the corner of every second page Davis includes a little fact on development with an image, and I thought this was a neat feature to keep children interested in multiple readings.
Cornell's illustrations were bright, fun and visually stimulating. I enjoyed how lifting the flap revealed an additional illustration.
Overall I thought the intention and visual design of the book were good, but felt that the textual content was not suitable for the target audience.

Story Rating: 2/5
Illustration Rating: 4/5
Image Source: http://www.workman.com/is/pshrink/products/covers/0761127321.jpg

No comments: