Author: Mary Lewis WangIllustrator: Gwen Connelly
Publisher: Children's Press
Publication Date: 1986
Award: N/A
Level: Start Off Stories, Level 1
Short Plot Summary:
The story begins when the Princess drops the ball she was playing with into the pond out of her reach. A frog appears and says he'll help her get her ball if she agrees to let him play with her in his house, eat with her and sleep near her. The Princess agrees and the frog gives her the ball. The Princess reluctantly fulfills her promise to the frog, and after she puts him to bed he suddenly turns into a Prince. He explains that a wicked witch turned him into a frog, and because the Princess was so nice to him, he magically turned back into a Prince.
Evaluative Comments:
I found that the ending was abrupt and rushed. Wang offered a very shallow explanation for how/why the frog turned back into a Prince.
The writing was done in short sentences with a limited number of lines to each page. There was a lot of repetition of words on the same page. For example, one page read: "My ball! My ball! I want my ball!" This repetition would be appropriate and satisfying for beginning Level 1 readers so that they could gain familiarity and confidence reading the words. There was also a Word List at the back of the story which would be useful for teachers or parents when selecting appropriate material.
The illustrations were romantic, cheerfully colorful and reminiscent of an older age. The illustrations seemed to be geared towards a female audience. I do not necessarily think this book would be popular amongst young male readers.
Story Rating: 2/5 (for content)
Illustration Rating: 3/5
Image Source: http://www.mostoriginal.com/images/jeremiah_was_a_frog_prince_jackie_fleming.jpg

No comments:
Post a Comment